2024 Articles

Why Do God and Humans Punish? Perceived Retributivist Punishment Motives Hinge on Views of the True Self

Lee, Young-eun; Dunlea, James; Solomon, Larisa Heiphetz

Laypeople often believe that God punishes transgressions; however, their inferences about God’s punishment motives remain unclear. We addressed this topic by asking laypeople to indicate why God punishes. We also examined participants’ inferences about why humans punish to contribute to scholarly conversations regarding the extent to which people may anthropomorphize God’s mind. In Studies 1A-1C, participants viewed God as less retributive than humans. In Study 2, participants expected God (versus humans) to view humans’ true selves more positively; this difference mediated participants' views of God as less retributive than humans. Study 3 manipulated agents’ views of humans’ true selves and examined how such information influenced each agent’s perceived motives. Participants viewed a given agent as less retributive when that agent regarded the true self as good (versus bad). These findings extend scholarship on lay theories of punishment motives and highlight links between religious and moral cognition.