2021 Articles

Where is the Overlap of Jewish Identity and Jewish Ancestry

Pollack, Robert; Pollack, Amy

In "Where is the Overlap of Jewish Identity and Jewish Ancestry?" Robert Pollack and Amy Pollack explore the complex interplay between Jewish identity and Jewish ancestry, emphasizing that while ancestry is rooted in biological and historical realities, identity is shaped by personal and communal choices. The authors argue that Jewish identity is not solely determined by one's DNA or genetic lineage but is instead deeply connected to cultural, religious, and ethical practices that are learned and adopted. They discuss how Jewish identity has evolved over generations, reflecting both continuity and change within the Jewish community. The essay highlights the importance of shared texts and traditions in forming a Jewish identity that transcends genetic ancestry, underscoring the fluidity and inclusivity of what it means to be Jewish. The Pollacks ultimately suggest that Jewish identity, while informed by ancestry, is primarily a product of lived experience and the choices individuals make in their engagement with Jewish life and heritage.