Theses Doctoral

21st Century Crime News Work: Empirical Infrastructure for a Fragmented Punishment Bureaucracy

Ben-Menachem, Jonathan

The United States operates the largest prison system in human history, and scholarship assigns news coverage a central role in its political development. Yet this literature treats crime news primarily as a cultural product.

This dissertation reconceptualizes local crime news as an empirical infrastructure for the carceral state: a system of workers and organizations who produce much of the publicly available knowledge about the routine operations of police, courts, and jails, institutions with limited capacity and incentive to document themselves. This infrastructure is contracting as newsrooms shrink. Drawing on interviews with 58 journalists across 40 local newsrooms in 24 states, I examine three contemporary pressures on the production of carceral knowledge.

The first study argues that reporters have become disembedded from law enforcement organizations, restructuring source relationships and enabling some to enact a critical professional role defined by alternative sourcing, structural framing, and a reinterpreted objectivity.

The second finds that crime reporters often succeed on audience metrics without orienting toward them, defending professional evaluation criteria even when quantification validates their work, with editors brokering commercial logics on their behalf.

The third shows how resource scarcity transforms homicide coverage into a choice among ethically unsatisfactory alternatives, explaining why coverage disparities persist even among practitioners who contest them. Together, the studies treat crime news as the product of contested daily decisions and argue that the conditions of that work are changing in ways existing scholarship has not examined.

Geographic Areas

Files

  • thumbnail for gsas-dissertations-001088.pdf gsas-dissertations-001088.pdf application/pdf 746 KB Download File

More About This Work

Academic Units
Sociology
Thesis Advisors
Western, Bruce P.
Degree
Ph.D., Columbia University
Published Here
October 21, 2026

Notes

Sociology, Criminology, Journalism, Organizational Sociology, Occupations