2023 Theses Doctoral
International-Standard Schools as a School Reform Modality: A Study of Policy Transfer from Nazarbayev Intellectual Schools to Regular Public Schools in Kazakhstan
For several decades, the institutionalizing of pilot projects has been part of school reform designs in many countries. In the context of developing countries, this reform design accumulated into the establishment of so-called International Standard Schools (ISS). ISS are not traditional private international schools but public institutions drawing on private sector initiatives. ISS are typically national projects based on borrowing educational innovations that have been long-standing practices and ideas in the private education sector and adapting them to the public education sector.
The exploratory case study focuses on the design of a scale-up reform wherein national actors involved international service providers in order to adapt and disseminate curricular innovations from the autonomous system of Nazarbayev Intellectual Schools (NIS) to the system of regular public schools. The study applies the notion of international standards as broadly defined international best practices and global education policies (e.g., competency-based education, outcomes-based education, and English as a medium of instruction) that national governments endeavor to adopt in their public school systems.
The study seeks to understand the national school system’s attraction to certain international standards and borrowing ideas and policies offered by international education providers in Kazakhstan. The study explores how and why the selection, local adaptation and scale-up of international standards occurred in Kazakhstan’s public school system. The study draws on case study methodology and combines an embedded single case-study approach with mixed methods research design. The application of this methodological strategy is explained by the complex nature of the scale-up phenomenon that requires the researcher to examine perspectives of heterogeneous actors involved in the development and implementation of the scale-up reform.
The study found that the design and establishment of NIS occurred due to the long-standing reforms characterized by a protracted policy conflict and the socially constructed modern school system based on the projections of various countries and regions as ‘world-class school’ systems. Avoiding the reduction of the state to one unitary actor, this embedded single case study found country-specific and sociological reasons for the establishment of NIS as a school reform modality in Kazakhstan from the perspectives of various policy actors including schoolteachers. The scale-up of curricular innovations had different meanings for different stakeholders of the same reform.
Geographic Areas
Subjects
Files
This item is currently under embargo. It will be available starting 2025-06-24.
More About This Work
- Academic Units
- Comparative and International Education
- Thesis Advisors
- Steiner-Khamsi, Gita GSK
- Degree
- Ph.D., Columbia University
- Published Here
- June 28, 2023