Academic Commons

Articles

Person Centered Healthcare and Clinical Research: The Necessity of an Evolutionary Hierarchy of Knowing and Doing

Wyer, Peter C.; Loughlin, Michael

Effective person-centred care requires recognition of the personhood not only of patients but of practitioners. This chapter explores the consequences of this recognition for major debates in medical epistemology, regarding clinical reasoning and the relationship between research and practice. For too long these debates have been dominated by false dichotomies - subjectivity versus objectivity, judgement versus evidence, reason versus emotion. Based on flawed understandings of such core concepts as “objectivity” and “engagement”, this distorted dissection of the subject-object relationship has served to depersonalise practice. The costs of this depersonalisation include over-regulation and micromanagement of healthcare processes by administrators and payers at the same time that information from clinical research remains under-utilized and the personhood of patients’ risks being ignored.

Science is a human practice, founded in a broader conception of human reasoning, ontologically dependent on human beings living and engaging with the world in social, emotional and ethical contexts. After looking at different conceptions of epistemic hierarchies and their uses in the analysis and evaluation of reasoning in a range of practice contexts, we propose a “nested hierarchy” that effectively turns upside-down the flawed evidence hierarchies that have helped to depersonalise care. T.S. Eliot’s “wisdom, knowledge, information” scheme (to which we add “data” below “information”) provides a model for a person-centred epistemic hierarchy. This crucial, person-centred inversion represents levels of awareness that characterize more or less developed thinking and judgment on the part of the particular practitioner.

Files

  • thumnail for Wyer Loughlin PCC and Clin Research 8(2).pdf Wyer Loughlin PCC and Clin Research 8(2).pdf application/pdf 299 KB Download File

Also Published In

Title
European Journal for Person Centered Healthcare
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5750/ejpch.v8i2.1847

More About This Work

Academic Units
Emergency Medicine
Published Here
August 19, 2020

Notes

Keywords: engagement, epistemic hierarchies, evidence, evidence-based medicine, judgement, knowledge, person-centered care, personhood, reasoning, science, wisdom