Theses Doctoral

Write to Be Read, Not to Be Graded: An Examination of Audience Awareness in Secondary Students’ Composition

Robbin, Jennifer Cohen

This qualitative study examined how high school students understand and enact audience awareness across multiple writing contexts. While writing instruction often assumes that students can transfer an awareness of audience across tasks, this study explored how students themselves described shifts in audience as they write for teacher-evaluated and more open or personally meaningful purposes. Drawing on student writing and interviews, the analysis revealed that audience awareness is not a stable skill, but a context-dependent practice shaped by institutional expectations and assessment structures.

Three patterns emerged. In teacher-evaluated contexts, students frequently orient toward an institutional audience, producing writing that reflects compliance with perceived expectations rather than communicative intent. In more open contexts, students demonstrate a broader sense of audience, marked by increased voice, affect, and rhetorical decision-making. Students also show a clear awareness of these shifts, describing tensions between writing to be evaluated and writing to be read.

These findings complicate assumptions about the transferability of audience awareness and suggest that classroom conditions play a significant role in shaping how students engage with audience. The study points to the need for writing instruction that creates space for more authentic rhetorical relationships and expands opportunities for students to write beyond evaluative frameworks.

Files

  • thumbnail for gsas-dissertations-000853.pdf gsas-dissertations-000853.pdf application/pdf 1000 KB Download File

More About This Work

Academic Units
English Education
Thesis Advisors
Vinz, Ruth
Degree
Ph.D., Columbia University
Published Here
October 28, 2026

Notes

English Education, Composition, Audience Awareness, Training of Teachers, Composition Pedagogy