Articles

Variant effect predictions capture some aspects of deep mutational scanning experiments

Reeb, Jonas; Wirth, Theresa; Rost, Burkhard

Background
Deep mutational scanning (DMS) studies exploit the mutational landscape of sequence variation by systematically and comprehensively assaying the effect of single amino acid variants (SAVs; also referred to as missense mutations, or non-synonymous Single Nucleotide Variants – missense SNVs or nsSNVs) for particular proteins. We assembled SAV annotations from 22 different DMS experiments and normalized the effect scores to evaluate variant effect prediction methods. Three trained on traditional variant effect data (PolyPhen-2, SIFT, SNAP2), a regression method optimized on DMS data (Envision), and a naïve prediction using conservation information from homologs.


Results
On a set of 32,981 SAVs, all methods captured some aspects of the experimental effect scores, albeit not the same. Traditional methods such as SNAP2 correlated slightly more with measurements and better classified binary states (effect or neutral). Envision appeared to better estimate the precise degree of effect. Most surprising was that the simple naïve conservation approach using PSI-BLAST in many cases outperformed other methods. All methods captured beneficial effects (gain-of-function) significantly worse than deleterious (loss-of-function). For the few proteins with multiple independent experimental measurements, experiments differed substantially, but agreed more with each other than with predictions.


Conclusions
DMS provides a new powerful experimental means of understanding the dynamics of the protein sequence space. As always, promising new beginnings have to overcome challenges. While our results demonstrated that DMS will be crucial to improve variant effect prediction methods, data diversity hindered simplification and generalization.

Files

  • thumnail for 12859_2020_Article_3439.pdf 12859_2020_Article_3439.pdf application/pdf 1.44 MB Download File

Also Published In

Title
BMC Bioinformatics
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12859-020-3439-4

More About This Work

Published Here
December 20, 2022

Notes

Sequence variation, Variant effect prediction, Deep mutational scanning, Non-synonymous sequence variant, Missense variant, Single nucleotide variant