Academic Commons


Reconsidering the “Idea” of Evidence in Evidence-based Policy and Practice

Mullen, Edward Joseph

Evidence-based policy and practice (EBP) has become an important social work conceptual framework. Yet, the core EBP concept, the concept of evidence, remains ill-defined. I propose a modification of the concept of evidence as applied to EBP effectiveness questions. As a basis for this reformulation ideas about evidence are examined from cross-disciplinary and multidisciplinary perspectives including epistemology, philosophy of science, evidence-science, and law. I propose that for EBP effectiveness questions: (1) to be considered “relevant evidence” an explanatory connection between an intervention and an outcome must be established rather than a mere association; (2) the EBP definition of “best available evidence” should include total available evidence (rather than a subset) about effectiveness, causal roles (i.e. mechanisms), and support factors and be inclusive of high quality experimental and observational studies as well as high-quality mechanistic reasoning; (3) the familiar five-step EBP process should be expanded to include formulation of warranted, evidence-based arguments and that evidence appraisal be guided by three high level criteria of relevance, credibility, and strength rather than rigid evidence hierarchies; (4) comparative effectiveness research strategies, especially pragmatic controlled studies, hold promise for providing relevant and actionable evidence needed for policy and practice decision-making and successful implementation.


  • thumnail for Reconsideringtheideaofevidence_post-print.docx Reconsideringtheideaofevidence_post-print.docx application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.wordprocessingml.document 496 KB Download File

Also Published In

European Journal of Social Work

More About This Work

Academic Units
Social Work
Taylor and Francis
Published Here
March 18, 2015
Academic Commons provides global access to research and scholarship produced at Columbia University, Barnard College, Teachers College, Union Theological Seminary and Jewish Theological Seminary. Academic Commons is managed by the Columbia University Libraries.