Academic Commons

Articles

Legal scholarship and digital publishing: Has anything changed in the way we do legal research?

Neacsu, Elena Dana

Scholarship, including legal scholarship, depends on the reliability of sources used so that subsequent scholars can build upon the work. Reliability is here defined as including accurate access to sources that reproduce faithfully the original source. Legal scholarship depends on the existence and reliability of accessible materials to verify the accuracy and validity of the ideas advanced in the source. The growth of digital publishing, which includes both distributing information directly in electronic format and the conversion of paper materials into electronic format, threatens the established reliability of source materials. The current legal literature has failed to address this issue; the author's examination of 20 Law Review articles, all containing at least four citations to the Internet, found that 12 of the 20 contained an online source which could no longer be accessed within a year of the online source's publication. The author suggests that librarians and scholars be aware of the risk digital publishing presents to future research.

Subjects

Files

  • thumnail for neacsu_legal_scholarship.pdf neacsu_legal_scholarship.pdf application/pdf 596 KB Download File

More Information

Published In
Legal Reference Services Quarterly
Volume
21
Issue
2/3
Pages
105 - 122
Academic Units
Diamond Law Library
Academic Commons provides global access to research and scholarship produced at Columbia University, Barnard College, Teachers College, Union Theological Seminary and Jewish Theological Seminary. Academic Commons is managed by the Columbia University Libraries.