2025 Theses Doctoral

Bearing the Burden of History: The Indo-Caribbean Madrasi Diaspora

Mehta, Gaurika

After the abolition of slavery in the British Empire in 1834, South Asians were shipped to plantations across the Caribbean as indentured workers. Indentured servitude—a system of forced migration and labor—produced the Indo-Caribbean diaspora. The Madrasis (named after their port of departure, Madras, i.e., Chennai, but hailing from different parts of southern India) are a religious minority within the Indo-Caribbean diaspora. They cohere around the goddess Mariamman and practice healing, drumming, and spirit possession rituals associated with her. Displaced by indentured servitude, persecuted by the colonial state for their religious practices, and ostracized by the Indo-Caribbean Hindu majority, Madrasis bear the burden of an exceptionally difficult transcontinental history. Since the 1980s, they have been moving to the United States as migrant workers. New York has emerged as the North American center of the Madrasi religion and diaspora.

To follow the Madrasis’ voyage across the dark waters of history and examine the role of religion in the making of the Indo-Caribbean Madrasi diaspora, I combine archival and ethnographic research conducted over the course of six years in New York, Guyana, and south India. Through archival work with maritime, missionary, and plantation records, I analyze how religion was employed as a category alongside race and caste to minoritize Madrasis. Through ethnographic fieldwork among Madrasi healers, drummers, and religious leaders in New York and Guyana, however, I demonstrate how the Madrasis themselves use religion in a very different way—to bear the burden of history. The Madrasis’ understanding of religion, history, and kinship, I argue, is shaped by their experiences of migration and creolization. From their diasporic position, the Madrasis imagine a transcontinental network of multibeing and multispecies kinship. They call this migrant network the “village.” This dissertation lies at the intersection of three geographical subfields in Religious Studies—South Asia, the Caribbean, and North America—and highlights the centrality of the study of religion to research on migration, diasporas, race, caste, and the environment.