Home

Should egg donors be paid? Exploitation or a woman's right?

Mark V. Sauer

Title:
Should egg donors be paid? Exploitation or a woman's right?
Author(s):
Sauer, Mark V.
Date:
Type:
Articles
Department:
Obstetrics and Gynecology
Volume:
314
Permanent URL:
Book/Journal Title:
BMJ
Abstract:
Paying women to donate oocytes has sparked much controversy. Interestingly, a duality of practice has evolved. In many parts of the world compensation is prohibited, while in some countries, particularly the United States, donating gametes is handsomely rewarded. It seems naive to presume a consensus will be reached regarding the correct approach. Furthermore, the United States is highly unlikely to curtail or regulate payments by law. Thus, supply and demand will inevitably continue to dictate policy, and the price of oocyte donation will escalate along with donor fees. There exists an inherent moral ambiguity in a practice of medicine that simultaneously places young women at risk of infertility while treating the childlessness of other women. Which need is paramount? Do benefits to one group far outweigh the risks posed to the other? These issues fascinate medical ethicists but torment practitioners who choose to provide services to women needing donor eggs.
Subject(s):
Obstetrics and gynecology
Medical ethics
Publisher DOI:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmj.314.7091
Item views:
116
Metadata:
text | xml

In Partnership with the Center for Digital Research and Scholarship at Columbia University Libraries/Information Services | Terms of Use